That's hardcore stuff right there.
That's hardcore stuff right there.I only get un-gapped rings and I'll gap myself to minimum OEM spec, then pull them after couple 100-miles and re-measure gap. Then grind another set with tighter clearances then repeat. Typically take 3-5 rounds until I see fretting marks at ends of rings. Then I put previous set back in
That what I keep hearing, that the plating is so thin that using a hone ball will strip it right away. They also say that it’s very pourous as well and even the aluminum oxide ball material gets trapped in the cylinder walls. I was told that as long as you can still see a cross hatch pattern take a green scotch brite to bad spots and rub lightly in an x pattern but do not put any type of hone in it. I had a motor mount tab that was welded back up and they found a fracture on the inside of the casing where he got it too hot. Could be fixed but nothing I wanted to spend so another case I went.I "deglazed" and cross hatched my scored nikasil cylinder once with a 3" 400 grit Aluminum oxide ball hone and oil. I tried to do as little as required to clean up the scoring. I suspected this was one of a few mistakes that led to engine failure. I got pits in the wall from the rings which eventually cracked them. This was mostly due to a bad tuning on the dyno but I always wondered if I weakened the cylinder walls by overdoing the honing. Now, I just have it plated for insurance. What did Millennium find that they cant repair? The damage shown below came back from Millenium looking better than new.
The type of piston for turbo isn't as critical as a good tune. The stock pistons are forged and can handle some abuse. They held up under 10-15 psi boost for many years before I pulled them to build a high boost motor. My JE low compression turbo pistons used in the scenario above blew after a few minutes on the dyno. The most important thing is the tune.
Any motor built to be turbo'd in the future would have to be stock compression or lower. I'd just build the n/a motor the way to think best and plan to build a turbo motor later.
I'd use new oem piston rings.
Code off of the case is BB. I’m just not sure how to cross reference these to the bearings. First time doing something like this with a motorcycle.L22223 is the number you need. Youll need the code off the cases as well
Assuming you mean all letters are on the LEFT side of case(BB forward of journal and BBA aft of journal).Anybody help me on the bearings?
case ID number - BB-BBA (BB is on left side case and BBA is on right side)
main journal o.d code is L22223
Other number above it is LBBBB
Turbodave you’re the best!! I really do appreciate you making that chart and being so straightforward on the info and making it simple. And yes, the bb-bba were both on the left side like the pic you posted. When I get home today I’ll look at the rods and see if they’re oem or aftermarket and I’ll get back with you. Thanks again!Assuming you mean all letters are on the LEFT side of case(BB forward of journal and BBA aft of journal).
View attachment 267405
View attachment 267404
I agree. Chances are, the recommended bearings may be on the loose end. The case journals shouldn't change size unless a bearing spun, but a used crank has certainly incurred some wear. As I mentioned before, even my stock motor didn't have the recommended bearing installed from the factory.Those specs are for brand-new parts. With used-parts, clearances will be larger. So measure existing clearances 1st, might need to select next size bearing. Final test with plastigauge again after installing new bearings. Make sure actual clearances are within spec.
When you mention the case journals that shouldnt change do you mean the bearings on the upper casing or lower casing?I agree. Chances are, the recommended bearings may be on the loose end. The case journals shouldn't change size unless a bearing spun, but a used crank has certainly incurred some wear. As I mentioned before, even my stock motor didn't have the recommended bearing installed from the factory.
I would not bother to take a plasti-gauge measurement using worn bearing unless you planned to use it. Take a measurement using a new bearing of a known size for determining the size you need. The bearings are $8 a piece and you need 10 of them. It sucks to buy them all and realize you'll have to buy more in a different size.
If you want to save some money, you can buy one pair of new bearings. Install them on one journal with the plasti-gauge. Install used bearing on the rest of the journals just to hold the crank centered. Torque main journal bolts to spec. Take a note of the plasti-gauge reading. Do this for the other journals using the new bearings until you have a plasti-gauge reading for each. You can figure your required bearing for each journal now. It will take longer, but you'll be left with at most one set of bearings you don't use.
Ahhhh okay, I’m understanding now. I’ll get a set of the yellow bearings and double check with the Plasti gauge and get another set of bigger bearing just in case.I mean since the outside of the bearing is held stationary by both the top and bottom case journals, they are not wearing against each other. The case journals(top and bottom) should have no wear. If it does, it spun a bearing, meaning the bearing spun with the crank and caused wear on the case journal. The case would be ruined if so.
The number on the rods you would look for are on the flat areas near the rod bolt. The one below is a "1".
View attachment 267413
How many times or how long did you run the flex hone for the cross hatch?I "deglazed" and cross hatched my scored nikasil cylinder once with a 3" 400 grit Aluminum oxide ball hone and oil. I tried to do as little as required to clean up the scoring. I suspected this was one of a few mistakes that led to engine failure. I got pits in the wall from the rings which eventually cracked them. This was mostly due to a bad tuning on the dyno but I always wondered if I weakened the cylinder walls by overdoing the honing. Now, I just have it plated for insurance. What did Millennium find that they cant repair? The damage shown below came back from Millenium looking better than new.
The type of piston for turbo isn't as critical as a good tune. The stock pistons are forged and can handle some abuse. They held up under 10-15 psi boost for many years before I pulled them to build a high boost motor. My JE low compression turbo pistons used in the scenario above blew after a few minutes on the dyno. The most important thing is the tune.
Any motor built to be turbo'd in the future would have to be stock compression or lower. I'd just build the n/a motor the way you think best and plan to build a turbo motor later.
I'd use new oem piston rings.
Thanks, I believe I’m going to use a scotch brite and go that route. I can still see the cross hatch very well with this motor. So I’m measuring clearances and I’m pretty much getting .025mm or .038mm with most being closer to .38mm.Not very long. I think honing the nikasil cylinders is just not a very good idea. If you must try it, here is something I found that might be of use. I copied the notes I had saved concerning nikasil but the website has more info.
BMW Airhead motorcycle cylinders, studs, shims, sealants, Nikasil, Galnikal, boring, honing
BMW airhead motorcycle cylinders, stud, studs, iron, Nikasil, Galnikal, boring, honing, shims, gaskets, sealantsbmwmotorcycletech.info
HONING SPECIFICS:
Honing is done on the old-style iron & steel cylinders, but not actual true honing on the Nikasil/Galnikal cylinders when doing a rings job (with few exceptions, see below). Honing may be done by a cylinder reclaiming company during the process.
Finish honing is best done with the SofTool brush hone made by Osborn International. Ball honing is adequate but not as good, as the ball tips wear after awhile and the hone does a poorer & poorer job. The SofTool does not exhibit such characteristics.
The crosshatch pattern is very important for ring break-in and wear, ring rotation, & even piston groove wear. The ideal proper angle is about 28°. If the angle is too shallow, the rings will rotate too slowly, the engine will use oil, the rings might also skate. If the angle is too steep, then starts can be rather dry, with fast ring and piston wear. The common 45° usually is OK ...but I DO think that 28° is better. Usually 220-280 grit stones are going to be OK.
If you must, or want to, hone a Nikasil/Galnikal cylinder, I suggest you use the "Brush Flex-Hone" which is also called a Ball Hone. www.brushresearch.com. Use only the aluminum oxide 240 hone. Do not use the silicon carbide hone 320, as there can be problems with that fast cutting hone. The purpose of the honing, IF you want to do it, on Nikasil/Galnikal, is simply to deglaze and clean up and prepare the surface for the new rings. Be exceedingly careful about using a aluminum oxide 240 grit hone. I try to avoid using such & might consider a much finer grit ...perhaps 600 or higher ...but! ...note what I do and do not. I do NOT hone Nikasil except in heavily glazed situations (very high mileage primarily). Even then I may not. I simply use 3M green industrial pads, soap and water, and my hand. Note that what I do is quite different than what Tom does, just below.
This is what Tom Cutter says (last such posting, AFAIK, was 04/08/2018, at least for the Airheads List):
"I always deglaze all used Nikasil cylinders with a 240-grit silicon-carbide Flex Hone* from Brush Research Manufacturing. and their proprietary honing oil. This restores a clean crosshatch that will facilitate rapid and complete ring seating. When rings are seated correctly, it is normal to see no measurable oil consumption between oil changes. (*This is NOT the material grit used on non-Nikasil cylinders.)"
THIS is what Tom Cutter said on a Facebook Airhead Group (I think this was November 15th, 2019):
"All BMW after 09/1980 production used Nikasil cylinders (or Galnikal, which was supplied by another maker but the same process. For those plated aluminum cylinders DEFINITELY use Aluminum Oxide, 120-grit Flex Hone with their Honing Oil. It is not at all inappropriate to re-hone a cylinder to restore a plateaued finish that will assure good ring seating with new rings.
"
Snowbum and Tom now agree much more closely, with that, above!...differing in the grit, however.
Yea I can try it the other way too. I tried my best to get it on the side of the oil groove. Came out alright but I’m also using the old journal bolts and I feel like it’s not torquing down enough. I’m afraid if I use my new journal bolts they will stretch or am I over thinking it? LolI think you should place the plastigauge parallel with the shaft and measure like below. You may have some squeeze into the oil groove the way you did it which would affect the outcome.
View attachment 267488